This special guest blog comes from Thomas Proctor-Legg, University of Oxford
Seminal research suggests that restorative practice in education is underpinned by the assumption that every young person brings a unique perspective, that they should be supported to express their thoughts and feelings, and that those most affected by an issue are best placed to find a way forward (Hopkins, 2015). Moreover, by recognising and valuing these unique perspectives, practitioners enable young people’s voices to be used to repair harm, build relationships and strengthen communities.
These opportunities are particularly important for young people with special educational needs and disabilities (SEND) or additional support needs (ASN), who often experience inequitable educational outcomes and whose experiences are frequently associated with harm. However, when it comes to research on restorative practice the voices of these particular young people are often missing.
The missing voices in restorative research
In 2025, I published a scoping study in Disability & Society (Procter-Legg, 2025b), exploring how young people with SEND were represented in research on restorative practice in education.
The study reviewed 546 articles published between January 2000 and November 2023, finding that only 24 centred SEND as their primary focus. Even within these studies, young people’s voices were largely absent, with research predominantly relying on quantitative data and adult perspectives.
Perhaps most strikingly, none of the studies positioned young people with SEND as knowledge creators, able to shape research questions, influence the research process or contribute to dissemination. Therefore, while restorative practice may lead to positive outcomes, such as reductions in exclusions and improvements in behaviour, we currently know very little about how young people with SEND experience this phenomenon.
Without these unique perspectives, our understanding of restorative work in education remains incomplete—but perhaps more importantly—we also risk reproducing the very inequalities that restorative practice seeks to address.
What happens when we listen?
These findings prompted me to undertake new empirical research documented through multiple case studies. The first of which is published in Emotional and Behavioural Difficulties (Procter-Legg, 2025a) and explores restorative practice through the experiences of young people with social, emotional and mental health (SEMH) needs in a specialist school in England.
Rather than beginning with adult definitions of restorative practice, I wanted to understand what mattered to these young people, what they thought about when I used the word restorative and how they experienced it in practice.
With this in mind, and after spending considerable time building rapport, I used walking-tour interviews whereby young people guided me around their school, choosing where we went and what they wanted to discuss.
What I found during these tours was that young people rarely described restorative practice through formal conferences or structured processes. Instead, they talked about safety, understanding, emotional regulation and the everyday maintenance of relationships.
They understood conflict as a normal part of life and an opportunity to learn, develop tolerance and strengthen relationships. Similarly, they described restorative interactions as small informal moments, sometimes involving conversations, but also movement, sensory environments, appropriate physical contact and opportunities for emotional regulation.
What was clear was that for these young people, restorative practice was not simply something that happened after harm. It was part of everyday life.
Rethinking restorative practice through a disability-informed lens
These findings encourage us to think about disability-informed spaces, such as the specialist school above, as spaces for innovation. Here, if we actively listen to the voices of young people, we have the potential to reshape how we understand restorative practice itself. This is particularly important if restorative practice is to be seen as a truly inclusive strategy.
Rather than viewing restorative practice, primarily as a one-off intervention designed to resolve conflict, we can begin to understand it as a broader developmental strategy. For young people with SEND, restorative interactions seem to support emotional regulation, self-awareness, communication, relationships and agency. These capabilities develop through repeated, everyday interactions. However, my time spent with these young people suggests that supporting their development requires flexibility and adapting processes to individual needs.
For example, a scripted restorative conversation may be appropriate for some young people, while others may need greater flexibility, or to focus on the pre-requisite skills needed to take part in these conversations.
Similarly, restorative circles may be successful if young people can sustain the long wait times associated with circle processes, the requirement to take turns, sit still, share objects and navigate the relational dynamics of the group. However, others may need movement, sensory support or alternative ways to communicate in order to be successful.
Importantly, this does not mean abandoning restorative practice when working with young people with SEND. Instead, it means recognising that maintaining fidelity to restorative practice requires adapting how it is enacted to meet the needs and circumstances of these young people. This raises an important question about what fidelity to restorative practice actually means in this context.
Drawing on the work of Corrigan (2012) and Hopkins (2015), my research suggests that fidelity can be understood through a tripartite framing, involving:
practitioners who balance the interaction between philosophical fidelity (values and principles), procedural fidelity (practices and frameworks) and contextual fidelity (the contextual aim of addressing harm) (Procter-Legg, 2026, p. 236)
This conceptual framing requires practitioners to balance these priorities in the moment, creating an inclusive approach through practitioner reflexivity rather than simply assuming inclusion due to the position of restorative practice within the educational discourse.
From voice to genuine participation
Although this research goes some way towards addressing the absence of young people’s voices, it also highlights how much further we need to go.
Laura Lundy’s (2007) model of participation provides a useful framework, identifying four essential elements: Space, Voice, Audience and Influence. Young people need opportunities to express their views, support to communicate, an audience willing to listen and, crucially, the ability to influence decisions.
Reflecting on my own research, the walking tours created opportunities for Space and Voice, while the analysis and publication sought to provide an Audience and Influence. Therefore, while young people shaped the conversations and findings in my study, more can be done to include them in setting the original research questions, designing the overall study or disseminating the results.
Being able to share the voices of young people in my research is a positive step forward. However, my hope is that future restorative research not only involves young people with SEND but goes one step further to include them in identifying research priorities, interpreting findings and disseminating results.
This will inevitably require us to recognise that participation will be different for each young person, while remaining committed to the principle that if voice is central to restorative practice, it must also be central to restorative research.
Further reading
Corrigan, M. (2012). The evidence base for restorative practices in NZ. http://www.rpforschools.net/articles/School%20Programs/NZ%20Ministry%20of%20Education%202012%20Restorative%20Practices%20in%20NZ%20The%20Evidence%20Base.pdf
Hopkins, B. (2015). From Restorative Justice to Restorative Culture. Revista de Asistenţă Socială, XIV(4).
Lundy, L. (2007). ‘Voice’ is not enough: conceptualising Article 12 of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child. British Educational Research Journal, 33(6), 927–942. https://doi.org/10.1080/01411920701657033
Procter-Legg, T. (2025a). ‘I think we’ve told you everything we can’: Exploring a restorative philosophy in action through the voices of young people with social, emotional and mental health needs. Emotional and Behavioural Difficulties, 31(2), 114–130. https://doi.org/10.1080/13632752.2025.2588535
Procter-Legg, T. (2025b). Restorative practice and young people with special educational needs and disabilities: A scoping study. Disability & Society, 40(12), 3463–3486. https://doi.org/10.1080/09687599.2025.2489363
Procter-Legg, T. (2026). Towards a restorative theorising of disability [Unpublished doctoral thesis]. University of Oxford.
The post Whose voices are missing? Restorative practice, disability and the importance of including young people in research appeared first on Children and Young People’s Centre for Justice.
Source: Raising Youth Justice – Children and Young People’s Centre for Justice Read More


