This special guest blog comes from Luke Devlin, Programme Manager for Interfaith Glasgow, leads on the Interfaith Restorative Justice Project, a partnership with The Faith & Belief Forum and Why me?

This year’s Restorative Justice Week theme of rebuilding communities comes at a crucial time for Scotland. In the summer of 2024, unrest swept parts of the UK following the tragic murder of three young girls in Southport. In a 2025 report, the Interfaith Restorative Justice Project noted that while such unrest had not taken place in Scotland, it cast a long shadow, and warned against assuming that ‘this couldn’t happen here’ by heeding the testimony of those in Scotland “who lived through those days in fear”. We knew of people from minority faith communities in Scotland who spent weeks in anxiety, often in contact with loved ones down south who were harmed by the disorder, warning them to stay home.

Those fears have proven well-grounded. Any sense of Scottish exceptionalism must now be challenged. Scotland has seen repeated anti-immigration demonstrations outside accommodation for people seeking asylum, and a delivery driver was attacked following an anti-immigration protest in Glasgow. We’ve seen an increase in reports of incidents of intimidation and violence. Hate crime charges in Scotland in 2025-26 were the highest since records began. For some communities and individuals, hostility has become part of everyday life. And when places of worship are targeted, the damage runs far deeper than broken windows or defaced walls: it strikes at people’s sense of safety, dignity, and belonging, and the fabric of the communities around them.

This acceleration of harm is taking place within a wider climate of polarisation and division, in which algorithmically-driven social media content can spread fear, misinformation and disinformation rapidly. While peaceful protest and legitimate disagreement about public policy are part of democratic life, prejudice, intimidation and violence undermine the common good that our relatively peaceful and pluralistic society depends on.

Interfaith restorative justice

The Interfaith Restorative Justice Project is a partnership of the Faith and Belief Forum, Why me? and Interfaith Glasgow, specialising in restorative processes that address harm and conflict in which religion and belief play a role, from restorative meetings after serious hate crime to listening circles and community meetings with people affected by hostility. Our Community Facilitators come from different faith traditions and work alongside statutory, social work and community partners in Glasgow and Solihull, and we are preparing a public report and a practical handbook to share our learning with restorative justice practitioners.

Harm which involves religion and belief often intersects with race, sex, migration status, social class and other characteristics, in ways that are not always easy to discern, even for those harmed or those causing the harm. Scapegoating of the ‘other’ takes many forms. Harm involving religion and belief is often tangled up with other parts of a person’s identity. Official figures count hate crime charges under separate categories (race, religion, sexual orientation, disability and others); the harm people describe often involves several of these together. For example, Muslim and asylum-seeking women could experience hostility that from being visibly Muslim, being women and seeking asylum, all at once.

Young people, belonging and online harm

I have a particular interest in how children and young people become exposed to extreme ideologies and how this can shape their behaviour. A 2025 report by the Children’s Commissioner for England found that a distrust of the police and a lack of youth opportunities fuelled the involvement of “disempowered” children in the 2024 riots.

Most were not motivated by far-right or racist views or online misinformation, but by ‘curiosity and the thrill of the moment’, having been ‘egged on’ by adults and often later filled with regret. One young boy said ‘I broke windows. The next day, I drove past those windows on the bus and I felt terrible.’

Exposure to extreme ideologies online is a separate concern, and one that Scottish teachers are raising, particularly about young men. In a recent article for Scotland’s Futures Forum, Dr Huw C. Davies describes Scottish teachers’ concerns about the influence of the far-right and the manosphere among pupils, and a fragmented online world of personalised feeds with little shared understanding of what others are seeing.

There is no single explanation for why a young person begins to adopt extreme or hateful views. The influences can include isolation, disillusionment, a search for identity and belonging, and the appeal of online groups offering recognition, status and purpose through hostility towards others. Recent research has also drawn attention to online nihilistic subcultures in which violence and cruelty can be celebrated for the attention and notoriety they bring.

Belonging, recognition and purpose are real developmental needs. Children and young people can find these through family, friendship, education, faith, sport, youth work and other communities. Accessible places, trusted adults, mentoring and meaningful opportunities to contribute. Otherwise, they may look for purpose and recognition elsewhere, in spaces that offer status in socially harmful ways.

Accountability, encounter and the possibility of change

What can restorative justice offer when a young person has caused serious harm in which religion and belief play a role? In one case we worked on, a young person convicted of a serious offence targeting a local faith community took part in a restorative meeting after sentencing. The offence had affected the wider faith community. Before the offence, the young person had experienced welcome and connection in that community.

Preparation for the meeting involved joint working between experienced restorative justice facilitators and the psychology, social work and support staff working with the young person. The facilitators also held preparation meetings with the young person and with the religious leader. Everyone taking part had time to decide what they hoped the meeting would achieve, with the right support.

At the meeting, the young person acknowledged the harm they had caused and expressed remorse. The religious leader offered forgiveness and wanted to hear about their hopes for the future. The meeting allowed both to encounter each other and work towards repairing the harm: in the words of the young person “this could never have happened in a courtroom”. The young person spoke of feeling at peace and wanting to build a better life, and of a wish to help others who might be influenced by extreme ideologies.

The work has continued since. Maintaining relationships and supporting the young person’s longer-term engagement with positive influences remains important as their circumstances change and they move through the justice system.

Listening, relationships and community cohesion

Restorative approaches can begin before any crime is reported. Listening circles give people affected by fear or hostility a voluntary space to speak, to be heard, and to connect with others in their community. In Springburn in north Glasgow, one such circle brought together Muslim women seeking asylum, after the fear and insecurity that followed the summer 2024 unrest in England.

They had been afraid for their own safety and for their children’s during this period. Not yet confident in English, they were limited in their ability to advocate for themselves and seek support. Being heard in their own language, through a skilled interpreter, came as a relief. One woman who had been very anxious said: “about 70% of my concerns have lessened in this session.” The community worker who supports the group told them how much she valued their presence in the community, and suggested creating more opportunities like this to talk.

The group were then supported through a process which led to a community circle bringing the women together with ‘community representatives’ in senior roles from the council, the police, a community support group and local schools, giving them a chance to bear witness to the women’s experiences.

“My daughter is too scared to walk down the stairs of our building alone in case someone will harm her,” one woman said. “I don’t know what to say to her to take away that fear.” Another described a friend whose headscarf had been pulled off: “The fear is with me all the time that someone will pull the scarf from my head and my daughter.” A third said: “I want to be part of the community.”

The representatives listened. One, who shared her own experience, said: “My mum has been here for 30 years and still struggles with language.” Another told the women: “You are so welcome, what you bring to our communities – there is a real richness.”

As the circle closed, one of the women said: “This is a new experience for us to have people from different organisations to hear us and want to help us with our problems.” The police and council representatives responded to requests for to a follow-up event: a community lunch and talk in a local church, where some of the women and members of the wider Springburn community learned about reporting hate crime and being an active bystander to safely intervene or document incidents of harm. “I learned a lot [of] information about [how] we can be safe in Glasgow,” one participant said afterwards. Another said:. “I love meeting different cultures and feel less lonely”. Through this process, the women built relationships with local services and their neighbours, the kind of relationships a community relies on when tensions rise.

Faith communities as active contributors

There is another important dimension to interfaith restorative justice. The Community Facilitators trained by the project came from Christian, Muslim, Jewish, Hindu and Buddhist backgrounds, and their work together gave practical expression to the relationships the project seeks to encourage.

Scotland’s faith and belief communities are not strangers whose place in Scotland needs to be explained or defended. They are part of the families, friendship groups, workplaces and communities that make up everyday life.

One facilitator reflected on the significance of a Muslim woman and a Jewish woman working alongside one another: “It was a good opportunity for people to see that we all get along: we care about each other.”

That kind of cooperation carries its own message. It makes solidarity visible, challenges assumptions about religious communities and creates opportunities for people to recognise shared concerns across differences.

Shared responsibility

Restorative processes like these now take place against a tide of misinformation that deepens polarisation and makes narratives of grievance and division seem normal. Faith and belief communities are often the targets of those narratives. They can also be among the people best placed to answer them, by meeting face to face, across traditions, with people who have been harmed and people who have caused harm. What does supporting that work require of restorative justice practitioners and policymakers in Scotland?

For practitioners, it means assessing each person’s behaviour and motivations individually. Research on radicalisation finds that individual, group and societal influences interact, and that no single factor predicts who will adopt extreme views or act on them.

Policymakers can help by recognising harm involving religion and belief as an area needing specialist restorative knowledge and training, and by making such restorative approaches available at every appropriate stage of the justice system. Preventative, community-level restorative work, such as listening circles, deserves sustained investment, because it can address harm before it turns into crime. Understanding more about what children and young people in Scotland are seeing online would help schools support them to recognise manipulation before it takes hold: treating radicalisation more like a scam that young people can learn to interrupt themselves, through “pre-bunking” that teaches them the tactics of targeting and attention-hacking. Faith and belief communities can also be valued as partners in delivering restorative justice and responding to hate, rather than seen only as groups needing protection or, at times, as part of the problem.

In this work I’ve seen attitudes change, relationships built and repaired, and people who had felt unheard begin to speak up for themselves. Desistance research finds that people stop offending through supportive relationships, a changed sense of who they are, and the chance to give something back to their community. The European Forum for Restorative Justice notes that restorative encounters can also help people in polarised settings see each other as human. Each relationship repaired across faiths and backgrounds makes division a little harder to sustain, and restores a little of the common good that prejudice, intimidation and violence undermine.

The post Rebuilding communities after hate: learning from interfaith restorative justice appeared first on Children and Young People’s Centre for Justice.

Source: Raising Youth Justice – Children and Young People’s Centre for Justice Read More